Sephora Jumbo Liner 12 Hour Waterproof Swatches and Review

I've been searching for a cream eyeshadow stick that won't crease or fade for years and have recently found my holy grail product in Mally's Evercolor Shadow Sticks (see my review here). But at $25 each, I knew I had to find a cheaper dupe or I'd go broke! 

The other day, I was at Sephora and came upon these 12 hour Jumbo Liners by Sephora's own private label. At $14, they're not exactly drugstore prices, but they're $11 less than Mally's Evercolor sticks which is significant! The question is...did they hold up? Let's find out!

What it Is: A jumbo eye pencil that can be used as eyeliner or eyeshadow.
What it Does: Resistant to water, heat, and humidity, these creamy pencils stay put for 12 hours.
What it Costs: $14
Where to Get It: Sephora stores and Sephora.com
Similar To: Mally Evercolor Shadow Stick
Quick Rating: Thumbs way up!

I chose the shade Taupe 04 out of 28 total shades. This line has a large variety of finishes from mattes to glitters, to shimmers.

This shade has a tiny bit of shimmer in it, but it's not obvious or glittery in any way. On the lid, it just translates to a beautiful shiny effect.
This crayon is so creamy and easy to work with. It glided across my lid so easily, I was sure that it wasn't going to hold up.
I was wrong!

I applied it around 10 am and did not use primer or any other eye makeup. I also applied it to my lower lash line, where I have the biggest problem with shadows and eyeliners migrating.

10 am- freshly applied.

 By 7pm, it hadn't creased at all, and although it wasn't quite as vibrant, the color was still even. It wore away a little in the inner corner of my eye, but not in a weird patchy way. It looked pretty much the way I applied it, just not as bright. Applying it over primer might solve that problem. Also, my lower lash line was still intact with no smudging at all!

7pm- going strong!

Overall, these crayons are amazing! They aren't greasy or heavy at all....they go on like a dream and dry to a super long lasting finish that doesn't budge.
My one and only complaint about these is that the cap does not fit tightly and keeps falling off. Not a dealbreaker, but I hope Sephora will fix that issue because even my cheap drugstore liners don't do that!
While these aren't cheap at $14 each, this is a mid-range product that performs just as well as it's higher-end counterparts.
I'm looking forward to trying more shades in the line, and I'm really hoping they come out with a gift set for holiday that has a few of these in it...we'll see

To purchase and see more reviews, please visit Sephora.com